Experience with these cheap bag inserts?

[dbarnes]

I'm shopping for a bag insert to use in an unstructured canvas bag. Has anyone tried these?

http://www.amazon.com/Padded-Velcro-.../dp/B003PDLI4Q

http://www.amazon.com/DSLR-Camera-In.../dp/B00348J5Q0

http://www.amazon.com/DSLR-Camera-In.../dp/B002R8FSWS

[januaryman]

That last one looks like the winner, but I never tried anything other than a bag designed for cameras. So I'm just expressing which one I would choose... I like the fact that the last one looks like it can be closed at the top.

[CK Dexter Haven]

If you're going 'thrifty' on the insert, stick a thick piece of foam on the (inside) bottom of the bag, beneath the insert. Just to cushion your kit every time you set it down.

[Rob-F]

Depending on what you want to carry, they all look pretty good. I liked #1. Moveable velcro pieces, places for four lenses.

[dbarnes]

Thanks for the replies. A lucky break created another solution for me. I'll post separately on that.