VC 35mm Ultron or Rollei 40mm Sonnar

[Spud10]

I've been contemplating making a purchase of one these two lenses lately, though I can't quite make up my mind. Aside from the size of the lenses and an approx 1.5 stop difference, what do you guys think?

I know these lenses aren't exactly the most well used lenses but anyone who could offer some experience with one or the other (or both!) would be fantastic.

[Spud10]

Have you by chance shot with the 50mm f1.5 nokton as well? It's currently my go to 50mm and I really find the way it renders quite pleasing to my eyes.

Any similarities?

[back alley]

i can't compare...never used the ultron...but i love the rollei sonnar...

look here

[fuwen]

The HFT 40mm Sonnar is sweet ......

http://www.fuwen.net/index.php?optio...=55&Itemid=116

[rover]

Originally Posted by back alley

i can't compare...never used the ultron...but i love the rollei sonnar...

look here

I am the opposite, love the Ultron but haven't used the Rollei Sonnar. I think the Ultron is a great 35mm lens. From what I have seen from the Rollei it looks very special too.

[Spud10]

Thanks for the links guys. I enjoyed the pictures, back alley, and fuwen, your website is great.

Really am liking the look of the sonnar but for some reason I keep thinking the ultron would be a better balance on my M5. Hmm..