35mm Hexanon or Summicron?

[Harry S.]

Hello.

These "this vs. that" threads are tedious and I feel guilty for starting another one. But you guys know what you are talking about and Im sick of following dead-end google searches.

I want a nice 35mm f/2 lens. I already have a Nokton and an Ultron but I find them too contrasty for Black and White, which is what I prefer to shoot. Results from the ZM lenses seem similar in contrast. I want a more classic look that still renders nice colour when required.

Basically, I like the examples I see from the Hexanon. But it is a hard to find lens, and the one currently on ebay is almost $1500 which is Summicron IV prices. It seems $1500 is a little expensive for both, considering the sales history. But I guess sellers are watching these forums and prices on valued M lenses is skyrocketting.

Im prepared to pay the price for a nice 35mm lens. So, which one?

Regards,
Harry

[wintoid]

I've had M-Hexanon 35mm, UC Hexanon 35mm and Summicron 35mm IV, and now own a Summicron 35mm Asph. They're all pretty modern and contrasty, with perhaps the M-Hexanon being the least so, but if I was looking for low contrast, I'd be looking elsewhere personally.

[Andrew Sowerby]

I agree, $1500 seems high for either of those lenses. If you want lower contrast you'd probably be better served with an older lens. Maybe a Canon? It'd be considerably cheaper too.

[venchka]

Toss the ZM 35mm Biogon into the mix.

You'll lose 1 stop. The Canon 35/2.8 (old all chrome LTM version) reportedly has "high resolution and low contrast." I've owned mine since forever. It's a nice lens and you'll never find one any smaller. After my recent Large Format GAS Attack I probably should sell it.

[deepwhite]

Some of my very experienced photographer friends told me that, if I want a 35mm for B/W, nothing beats a Leica Summicron 35/2 I, the famous 8-element. I've checked out some samples on the internet and they certainly have that "old and elegant" flavor. Worth checking it out.

[SolaresLarrave]

You'd have to analyze meticulously and obsessively to tell the difference between these lenses if you do it from a print. I'd say wait up for the one that comes up within your budget. Also, look into stores because eBay isn't the only source of these lenses. There was a time when Robert White's store in the UK carried them new (about two years ago). Have you searched the online stores from NY?

I went for a Konica, and even though later I purchased a 'lux, I'm not parting with my Hexanon. Don't make me an offer.

Good luck! :)