PDA

View Full Version : releases required for EU STREET photography contest


memphis
03-29-2008, 07:19
http://www.amateurphotographer.co.uk/news/European_Union_EUs_street_photography_contest_dema nds_subjects_permission_news_200766.html

The European Union (EU) is encouraging photographers to take part in a street photography competition that, under strict rules, requires permission from all people being photographed.

Launching its 'Cultures on my street' campaign today, organisers state: 'All European residents, regardless of age or origins, are invited to participate. It's as easy as grabbing your camera and stepping outside the front door.'

However, a close look at the rules reveals that participants 'must prove' that all individuals depicted in the submitted photos have agreed for their image to be used and that they 'posed voluntarily'.

Subjects pictured must sign a model release form (pictured), giving permission for the European Union to make free use of their image.

The competition forms part of the European Year of Intercultural Dialogue 2008.

Subjects can represent themes such as education, religion, science, the arts, culture, minority groups and youth.

Photo enthusiast John Kelly, who was stopped by police while taking pictures in Blackpool last month, believes the rules will lead to 'contrived' pictures and that photographers will have problems getting permission from subjects. 'I would find it difficult myself,' he told us, questioning when is the right time to ask such permission for the purposes of a natural photograph.

Challenged over the rules, a competition spokesman told us that the model release rules 'are not meant to inhibit photographers going about their everyday business'.

He said they are included as a 'common courtesy' to ensure people are aware that their image may be used on promotional booklets and on posters across Europe.

The spokesman added that with different laws in each country it would be difficult, logistically, to draw up different rules for each nation.

The contest's €15,000 prize pot includes photo equipment and trips to European cities.

Organisers add: 'Everyone has a story. Now that the borders within Europe are fading, people from an even greater mix of cultures and backgrounds are coming together, mingling their voices in an ever-growing dialogue of their unique stories and experiences.'

The closing date is 30 June and winners will receive their prizes at a ceremony in Brussels, Belgium, in September.

Rules state that entrants must also agree to the subsequent use of their photo by the European Commission in relation to the European Year of Intercultural Dialogue 2008.

Images can be uploaded to www.street-cultures.eu

nikonhswebmaster
03-29-2008, 07:45
Yes once you take photos out of a museum or photo show context and move them to any arena that might be considered commercial (such as the EU supporting hotels resorts etc on the same page) you are going to need press releases in most countries.

Pretty standard stuff for any form of advertising. Still a nice prize! Carry forms.

Pitxu
03-29-2008, 07:48
I can't see what the organisers are going to do with the photos. (suspicious).


It could also be an opportunity for the "authorities" to build a data base of the names and addresses of "street shooters", (potential trouble makers).

Spyderman
03-29-2008, 08:18
This could only happen in E.U.

Such a bureaucratic organisation... there are forms and rules for everything. Even how to pee...

RML
03-29-2008, 08:20
The entered photos are not going to be the free street photos we're accustomed to here on RFF. They'll be posed, set up photos, with the subjects fully aware of their being in the shot. That could work well, or not at all. I can think of a number of minorities and groups of people here in Holland alone that would be rather hesitant to have their faces splattered all over Europe. I don't see many Muslims voluntarily letting me shoot them, especially not with a Europe-wide audience. And neither would most youths from subcultures. Unless of course I want to submit photos of Muslim women in burka or youths with their faces covered with scarves. Yet, these groups of people are important aspects of life in Holland, and Amsterdam in general.

I guess I'll have to stick with... well, I don't know who I'll stick with, really.

gb hill
03-29-2008, 08:50
Blackpool is the same city that banned the Rolling Stones 44 years ago.
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/main.jhtml?xml=/news/2008/03/27/nstones127.xml

lZr
03-29-2008, 09:28
The photos can be manipulated....?!

migtex
03-29-2008, 09:57
With the release necessary for Street photography we end up with this type of photo...


http://img98.imageshack.us/img98/610/f1000024asnik5cmbw40080gr8.jpg


really interesting...
BTW I have 4 or 5 different races on this pic.... but you just have to take my word for it...

PetarDima
03-29-2008, 09:59
that's not fair! Serbia, Croatia etc. we are not in any part of the world:mad: ... well, they don't can't allow photographers from this region to show their work:
1. we are too good shooters for their taste :p
2. mixed culture? This part of Europe is right place to make photos about this topic.

http://i66.photobucket.com/albums/h272/PetarDima/50eb84e2.jpg

Nh3
03-29-2008, 10:10
Its common practice to get release form if you wish to publish the photos but photos taken on public places does not require release from... can you imagine celebrities signing a release from for each picture of theirs?

Sine this is a government back initiative they wish to be on the safe side and avoid law suits that's why they're asking for release forms.

migtex
03-29-2008, 12:32
I did understood, still, most (if not all) of the photos to be presented must be "setup", not natural.
It's kinda hard to get everyone on a street photo like the one above to sign anything....

halenger
04-01-2008, 03:43
They must surely be aiming at digital photographers or photographers who are good enough to know they'll be happy with a shot.

I couldn't see myself asking for a model release for every shot I take, in the off chance that one works out. It's all well and good when you know what you are doing or can chimp with a digital.

robert blu
04-01-2008, 10:09
no special comment from my side, bu just as information in Italy you are NOT allowed to use any picture with people in it if you have not a permission of them. You are not allowed to print on a magazine, to make an exhibition in your local photo club or to post in the net. Not nice but it is the law. Not sure but probably the same law apply to other EU country.
The law was made after the mis-use of photo taken with mob phone and post in the net and consequence of it someone was cauhgt where it should not have been (I guess swimming pool with g-friend instead of extra time in office !).
rober

Florian1234
04-01-2008, 13:47
I think - well that's what I understood from the legal text - that you don't need permission of the person in the photo here in Germany, when you make the photos as a form of "higher art". If not - well then you have to ask everyone in the photo for permission to publish the shot (in any form). :rolleyes:

I declare I do it as higher art. :D


(but yes, somehow it is a bit suspicious that the EU comes out with such a project. Also "that" quick after some of our British friends here on RFF handed in their thoughts to their parliamentary appropriates.)

srichmond
04-02-2008, 03:43
What business does the EU have coming up with rubbish like this? It's like the German or UK government having a photo competition and making up stupid rules. Haven't they got better things to do?

I bet the winner is some faceless bureaucrat, and the whole thing is a corrupt farse.

Pitxu
04-02-2008, 03:54
Nowhere do the organisers state what the photos will be used for...

Cui bono?

Florian1234
04-02-2008, 08:28
They state it indirectly - by writing something about giving them the right to use it for advertisment etc. about such as "happy EU ethno-mix living" .

sirius
04-02-2008, 08:47
I'm not sure why people would be bothered by the rules in the EU contest. They make sense to me. I don't know if you are aware of the changes in the law in France. People now have the right to decide how their image is used. Things have changed and the EU rules must be done to avoid creating a scandal or legal mess.

Doisneau's famous photo of people kissing in front of the Hotel de ville was done with models. I imagine that it's this kind of street photography that will be needed for this contest. Yes, it's a different way of working, a more journalistic approach, however it can still produce good results.