Wheat or chaff?

[aliceelizabeth]

http://a494.ac-images.myspacecdn.com/images01/13/l_ea71b6fa73c135de1e1d9e62a2b1fea5.jpg

[Sparrow]

I like the composition, elements falling on the 1/3rd nodes keep my attention in the centre well, but despite liking “dark” photos I think the lack of shadow detail would put it in the gap between the two for me, not chaff but not quite wheat, oats perhaps :)

[aliceelizabeth]

oats is good, I shouldn't expect more when gleaning :)

[nikon_sam]

I like it...really like the light coming through the opening...but having a tough time with the guy on the phone...if he was smoking or just gazing out the window...or maybe just looking into the lens...Wheat with a little chaff still in it.

[aliceelizabeth]

I know, mobiles, so unromantic compared to fags :). I think, on the advice from here and other forums, I'm keeping it but merely as a shoe-box-photo.